I was going to say SW Alabaster too, but I’m not sure with Wyndham Cream, but only because I’m not familiar with that color.

Regarding buying a sample, I’m sorry to complicate things, but SW alabaster samples are tricky for a couple reasons. One is it doesn’t divide evenly from gallon to quart for sampling so your sample color won’t match the actual paint used. Another is, the SW sample paint is a different base white than the trim paint you would use, so again it wouldn’t match. Also, the sheen affects the look of the color. To paint a true sample of SW alabaster you have to get it in a gallon of whichever SW paint type and sheen you would be using. I learned this the hard way with this color, but confirm at the SW store yourself!

We did SW wool skein with SW dover white trim.

I have wool skein with dover white trim also.

i currently have Wool Skein in kitchen with Dover White trim-semi gloss, but really like Alabaster!

lawsyes,

What color dId You choose?